The Pipestone Indian Training School

In the 1890s, the U.S. built the Pipestone Indian Training School on reserved quarry land and legal conflict soon followed.¹²  The Pipestone Indian Training School was one of many boarding schools that separated Native children from kin and land in order to assimilate them into American economy and society.¹³ These schools came about as attitudes towards the “correct” treatment of Native people turned towards assimilation with the passage of the Dawes Severalty Act of 1887. Many Native people resisted boarding schools, but the Pipestone Indian School inspired particularly active resistance for two reasons. First, it was built illegally on Yankton Sioux reservation land. Second, during the school’s tenure, management of the quarries fell largely to the white superintendent of the school instead of the Yankton people.

The Yankton’s resistance resulted in a complex battle for legal recognition of Yankton ownership of the quarry land. The conflict was not resolved until 1926, when the Supreme Court determined in Yankton Sioux Tribe of Indians v. United States that the building of the school violated the 1858 Treaty of Washington. The court determined that the Yankton Sioux were owed compensation.¹⁴  In 1928 the Yankton Sioux were paid $328,558. Ironically, in return for this compensation the Yankton Sioux were forced to cede control of the quarry land to the National Park Service (NPS).¹⁵

Prior to the beginning of the NPS’s management of the quarries, the last visit by any active quarriers was in 1911. The Yankton people apparently had not quarried the site since 1899. In 1937 the area was designated the Pipestone National Monument and in 1946 the NPS finalized and implemented a permit system for quarrying, open to legal members of any American Indian tribe. This meant the Yankton were now unable to prevent other tribes from quarrying the stone. Additionally, they were forced to apply for a permit to quarry from the superintendent of the Pipestone Indian School, which did not close until 1953. Quarriers from a variety of tribes migrated back into the area, and many settled there permanently, supporting themselves on money earned from the sale of finished pipes. In 1954, the Pipestone Indian Shrine Association (PISA) was founded by Native peoples to regulate trade and work with the NPS to improve and update the cultural center and museum in the park. They also worked to ensure that the ancient art and practices of quarriers and pipemakers continued. For many years, these local quarriers were the main representatives of Native American culture in the area around Pipestone.¹⁶ 

• Hal K. Rothman, and Daniel J. Holder, "Managing the Sacred and the Secular: An Administrative History of Pipestone National Monument" (Hal K. Rothman and Associates, 10 September 1992) http://www.cr.nps.gov/history/online_books/pipe/adhi.htm 17 May 2006. ↩

• National Park Service, "Pipestone Indian School Superintendent's House," National Park Service: A National Register of Historic Places Travel Itinerary. Accessed July 11, 2015. http://www.nps.gov/nr/travel/pipestone/sup.htm. ↩

• 272 U.S. 351 Yankton Sioux Tribe of Indians v. No. 250 United States. Argued 7 October 1926. Decided 22 November 1926. http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/cgi-bin/getcase.pl?friend=nytimes&court=us&vol=272&invol=351 30 May 2006. ↩

• Rothman, Managing the Sacred and the Secular, 24. ↩

• Rothman, Managing the Sacred and the Secular. ↩